Hey, you’re still reading Tit for Tat’s 2014 Emmy coverage. After discussing the TV movie and its four acting categories, it’s time to close of this section with the newly revived Miniseries category. Since the combination of both TV movies and miniseries three years ago, only one miniseries has won against a TV movie. So this is quite a refreshing comeback. That said, this is a very empty category as proven by the fact that there are only 16 miniseries eligible, and with that small group, it even ended up with six nominees (as opposed to the regular five). Here are the six nominees for this year:
For the third year in a row, the American Horror Story series gets in, and Coven is a great departure from the underrated Asylum. As for starters, it has the trio of Jessica Lange, Kathy Bates, and Angela Bassett at the helm. Just when you think that the Emmys interest with AHS would decline, they come back not only with a whimper but with a bang. This year’s series received 17 nominations, the same as last year, but now with Directing and Writing to boot. I’d say this is the closest year they ever had of possibly scoring that Emmy win.
Then we also have A&E’s Bonnie & Clyde. Welp there’s really nothing much to say about it given that this is the show’s only nomination, so it’s pretty much obvious that this is the filler sixth contender here. Maybe having the prominent duo of Craig Zadan and Neil Meron would siphon some votes, but even I really doubt that.
The miniseries adaptation of the Oscar winning movie Fargo was a risk for FX, but it’s a risk that certainly paid off. The first season wasn’t only met with critical acclaim, it also had ratings under its belt. And surely, some Emmys as well (with the Allison Tolman upset that I’m currently predicting). This show garnered 18 Emmy nominations this year, the highest for any miniseries, and the second overall only behind HBO powerhouse Game of Thrones. It’s clear that the nominating panel love it, and I can’t blame them for doing so.
Now to represent the British bloc comes second time nominee Luther. After getting its first nod in 2012, the show’s final season is nominated once again this year alongside a Writing nod and one for lead actor Idris Elba. While the Emmys doesn’t have a total hard on as compared to the Oscars, history has shown that they give exceptions every now and then as proven by Downton Abbey‘s domination in 2011 and last year’s Screenplay upset by The Hour‘s Abi Morgan. Let’s see if Luther can have the same fate too.
Like Bonnie & Clyde, The White Queen also gets their only Emmy nod this year for miniseries. The lack of both Rebecca Ferguson and Janet McTeer in the acting categories, nor The Final Battle in Directing indicates that the Emmys aren’t just into this show at all.
And lastly, HBO’s bet in this category is
True Detective Treme. Now on its closing season, the show has finally gotten into a series category for the first time and even with a writing nod to boot. Prior to that though, its only Emmy mentions were a Directing nod and a Song nod way back during its initial season. This indicates to me that this, more than anything else, is just the result of a weak and empty category.
Basically, it all boils down to American Horror Story: Coven vs. Fargo. While Coven got 17 nods, Fargo topped it with 18. Meanwhile, Fargo is less one total acting nod with 4 as compared to Coven‘s 5. Both shows got in for Directing and Writing but Fargo has two Directing nods as compared to AHS‘ one. That said, I think the telling factor here is that the clamor and acclaim for Fargo is definitely much stronger and more consistent than AHS. I think that’s what makes me predict for a Fargo win. Now if only we got this one a real race between True Detective and Fargo, it would have made the race more enjoyable to predict.
Alternate: “American Horror Story: Coven“
02. “American Horror Story: Coven“
05. “The White Queen“
06. “Bonnie & Clyde“
You can see my other 2014 Emmy prediction analysis here.
For more Emmy talk, you can also follow me on Twitter: @nikowl